May 29 – Hill 62 and Passchendaele

We began our day at the Menin Gate again for a discussion. We discussed two Victoria Cross recipients, Hall and Mackenzie. We also talked about the evolution of artillery, barbed wire, and machine gun tactics. The advent of continuous-wave radio during the late war was also explored.

After, we visited the steadily sloping plains around St. Eloi, where Canada was again victorious. At Railside Dugouts cemetery, we visited the gravesite of Dr. Milner’s great uncle. We returned to the Grote Markt square for a baguette.

Then, we went to Hill 62, Mont Sorrel. Here we saw where the Germans displaced the Canadians from the hill, only to be thrown back after successive, determined Canadian counterattacks. We saw Maple Wood and Sanctuary Wood, where we explored an accurate trench replica that featured realistic underground tunnels. Hill 61 was also in the distance.

Next was Passchendaele. We stood on Bellevue Spur, one of the two prominences along the Ypres-Passchendaele axis. In 1917, the entire Canadian Corps (four divisions and its artillery) passed along these two ridges – which were fiercely guarded by a network of German pillboxes – to get to their objective. The valleys below held a sea of mud and were impassable. This meant that tens of thousands of men crossed an area of operations of less than three kilometres in width.

We then visited the Crest Farm monument, and Tyne Cot cemetery. It is astonishing that one million Allied soldiers were casualties between Ypres and Passchendaele; a ten-minute drive. These numbers were matched on the German side.

– Michael Kryshtalskyj

First Impressions

Today was the first official day of the tour. We landed at the Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport, and after a long wait in the terminal, we departed. Most of us fought off sleep as the tour commenced. The dense city of Paris opened up into the sprawling countryside as our vans followed their paths out towards Belgium. Small villages dotted the landscape, intermingled with pockets of trees. It was a gorgeous site to take in, especially for someone like myself who has had no experience outside of North America. The beauty of the landscapes shared their space with the objects placed by man. The tight streets and old buildings characteristic of the region were actually replicas of structures lost long ago. The Two World Wars had taken their toll on this region, though it seemed barely visible at this point in time. As far as I knew, the area had been restored to pre-war conditions. As we drove further out of the city, we were faced with dismal reminders of the cost of conflict. Nearly every village we passed had at least one memorial to commemorate the fallen as well as the headstones to mark their final resting place. In the recesses of my imagination, the beautiful French and Belgium landscapes gave way to war-torn soil as the lush green grass turned to thick mud. The rolling hills became trenches tens of kilometres long with layers upon layers of debris, razor wire, and a variety of guns and defensive structures. I could picture it now: the grisly scenes of men, some no older than I, climbing over the tops of trenches, sprinting with their weapons drawn to face the enemy. As the casualties were read out to us, the horrors of attritional warfare became so much clearer. As part of our first day on the road, we visited the Brooding Soldier, a museum in Peronne, the Menin gate ceremony, and the place of the second battle of Ypres. Although the tour was fairly lighthearted as we visited monuments and museums and sampled delicious cuisine, the images of the war stuck with me. Every step I took today was preceded by that of a soldier marching to war. I feel that this imagery is going to set the tone for the entirety of this trip as we attempt to revive the sacrifices made on this blood-soaked soil.

Emilio G. Caputo

Day One: Living History

The day started early, when our flight landed at 9 am local time. We had a brief delay while our intrepid leaders collected the vans (as with any vehicle rental, this was not without its complications), and then we were off – officially under way for the 2016 Canadian Battlefield Tour!

Our first stop was the Historial de la Grande Guerre in Perrone. This was really a new and unique museum experience. Instead of mannequins modelling the uniforms, most were laid out on the floor, many with arms and equipment that the men would have carried. This layout certainly put things in a new perspective. It made it clear that this was not just another war museum – the Historial has a message for visitors. One of the images which has stayed with me all day is the presence of a flute in an exhibit dedicated to the new types of wounds and physical suffering this war inflicted. The flute belonged to Georges Duhamel, a doctor who voluntarily became a surgeon to the armies. The flute is such a personal item, a leisure item, and seems almost out of place in an exhibit discussing war wounds. But this, I think, is the point. These men were people, first and foremost. They were real, they breathed, laughed, fought, and died – and some of these things we were looking at, that we are so privileged to be able to examine at our ease, brought them some small measure of comfort in the horrors they faced every day.

The Historial also offered an exhibit of Otto Dix’s etchings. Otto Dix was a young German who served in World War I and after the war was left with psychological wounds so deep he did not know how to heal them. In the 1920s, he began this extensive collection, transforming the images of the atrocities of war from his tormented mind into the etchings he is best known for today. These etchings are the stuff of nightmares, and you cannot walk away from them without some deeper understanding of what permanent damage the war inflicted.

From Peronne, we continued on to Ypres, and the site of the Canadian war memorial there. I was first struck by the sheer size of the monument itself. It towers over visitors, commanding respect and reverence. Arrows in the stone floor point in the directions of various battlefields, among them Passchendaele, Langemark, and Hooge – just a few of many. We took a minute to let the importance of this place sink in. This monument to the fallen, to the men who withstood the first German gas attack, left me feeling small. It is one thing to read about history, but here it is coming to life for us. How fortunate are we, to be able to stand in this place, free and at liberty to do as we wish. The entries in the guestbook indicate that I am not alone in this sentiment. There was another detail about Ypres which impressed me: the extraordinarily well-kept plants and grass. These men are remembered, and respected, and I for one am humbled to be able to pay my respects.

The final stop on this rather emotional day was a viewing of the ceremony at the Menin Gate. This monument stands in the city itself, and this ceremony takes place every day at 8 pm. One cannot helped but be moved by the buglers, the wreath layers, and the simple knowledge that the walls of this enormous arch are inscribed with the names of men whose final resting place remains unknown – and there are thousands of them. I am certain there will be more detail on this ceremony tomorrow, as three of our own will participate in laying a wreath on behalf of the CBF.

There is much to see and do in the next two weeks, but of this I am certain: we do not take this tour alone. We are guided by the memories of those who never came home, and reassured by the knowledge that they are, always, remembered.

-Shelagh Prowse

In Conclusion

Tomorrow we return to Canada, our two week journey through four countries and two wars complete. When I applied to take part in this study tour I had hoped that it would give me a fuller understanding of the World Wars and Canada’s participation in these conflicts. Upon reflection I realize that I have learned so much more.

A prof of mine this past year, the same one who encouraged me to apply for this study tour, said that the ground is a primary resource. You can understand an event and its impact so much more by being in the space where that event took place. To see the trenches, the craters, the leftover bunkers and batteries scattered throughout Northern Europe is to see the physical imprint of war on the land and its people. To see cemeteries, dozens over these past two weeks, filled with tens of thousands of graves, is to truly understand the magnitude of the sacrifice given by the “lost generation” and to feel the sense of loss experienced by families and communities the world over. I have walked through cold and damp underground tunnels, I have stood on ridges and between the walls of a trench, and I have mourned over the graves of so many lost. These are experiences and knowledge that cannot be pulled from the pages of a textbook.

I think I speak for everyone when I say that I’m very grateful to have had the opportunity to participate in this study tour. I had anticipated that the academic value would be immeasurable, but today I realized how beneficial it is to tour Europe with knowledgeable and enthusiastic guides like Geoff and Dave. They are so filled with wonderful stories and facts. As we wandered through cemeteries Geoff would stop and tell us the individual story of a man buried in front of us. As we passed through city streets Dave pointed out minute details and told us about the events that had taken place in the very place we were standing. I know I never would have had such a fulfilling experience here had it not been for their excellent guidance.

In conclusion I would just like to say thank you. To Geoff and Dave for their outstanding leadership. To my peers and now friends who were excellent company when we were all so far from home. And of course, thank you to CBF for making this all possible.

Madison Stirling